<$MTGreetFacebookCom The OPD's freedom to act with impunity - Luther rose colored glasses

The OPD's freedom to act with impunity

| 6 Comments | No TrackBacks

The Umbrella 4 hearing was scheduled for this morning at 9. To explain briefly, the Umbrella 4, Sri, Alexandra, Nichola and Rita, were all ticketed at Frank Ogawa/Oscar Grant Plaza in Oakland last November for a charge that was issued for not removing the umbrella that the Interfaith Tent was using after the Occupy Oakland encampment was evicted from the plaza weeks earlier. Without the details in front of me, the charge was one that is specifically geared toward permanent structures; while the Umbrella that we were using was one that was put up and taken down in the matter of ten minutes. The citations were inappropriately issued, and these four brave women were determined to dispute the charges, represented by noted civil rights attorney Walter Riley.

Interfaith Tent Umbrella 3 Jan 2012.jpg

I hopped aboard a 72R bus at San Pablo and 40th and rode down to the Wiley W. Manuel Courthouse this morning to attend the hearing. There I met Nichola who was already talking with Mr. Riley, and soon Rita and Alexandra arrived as well as some other supporters (Sri's charges were never filed with the court and she was not present). The hearings scheduled for room 103 were moved to room 102, which is ordinarily traffic court, and had been rescheduled for 8:30 without notification of the pertinant parties. Riley stepped into Room 102 when it opened and returned shortly after, notifying us that the hearings had taken place. Alexandra and Nichola's charges were vacated because the police officers were not present, but Rita was found guilty, as Officer Romero, the one who issued her citation, was present, and Rita was not (not having been informed of the time change).

The court is entirely neglectful by rescheduling hearings without notifying the parties. This case will be reheard and dismissed, because Rita has the right connections with a group of people with the wherewithal and determination to take a stand on abuse of the power of civil authorities. But this small incident underscores the much larger and deeper injustice issues involving some police agencies and the Oakland Police Department in particular.

The OPD acts with complete impunity, issuing citations under the auspices of maintaining the peace. As often as not, people do not have the ability to dispute or fight such charges, and may not even be aware that the charges filed against them are invalid. People who do wind up in the system are inordinately people of color.

In cases where the OPD is found accountable, they wind up being slapped on the wrist. Take last month's decision by the Oakland City Council to pay punitive damages issued by a judge to former Officer Ingo Mayer for performing an unlawful strip search. The city, already having been itself fined $205,000 for its policies, decided that it was also responsible for the individual misconduct of one of its officers. What effect this has, however, is that even when an officer is acting on bad behavior, and that officer has been found culpable, the city of Oakland will step in and use taxpayer money to protect that officer, thereby providing more cover to the OPD.

OPD at Move-in Day 28 Jan 2012.JPGThe Oakland Police Department gets cover from the civilian population as well. In a city with notoriously high crime rates with a significant ethnic diversity (almost a quarter each non-hispanic Black, non-hispanic White, and Hispanic, with another 16% Asian), some areas are more demanding on the police department than others; and a large number of residents are loathe to do anything to "break" an already fragile and understaffed department. Given its history, a good half of Oakland's residents have no trust of the department at all, and are not willing to use a city service that may just as easily turn on them for no good reason.

After a judge in January ordered oversight for the Oakland Police Department, it became blindingly obvious that this abuse-ridden organization needs to change, but given the lack of willingness from external sources such as a city manager who refuses to provide accounting for it, and a populous fearful of rumblings of increased crime statistics, the change needs to come from within. 

Despite the results emerging from this seriously broken system, individual cops are not inherently evil. A design flaw in this justice system is the objectification of people who are members of a particular ethnic or racial group is designed to turn human beings into criminals in the minds of cops as well as the "public" at large.

Why does the city of Oakland, which ought to be in the forefront of the fight for social justice, continue to have institutions that systematically promote those social evils of racism and classism? Things should be different here.

The OPD is a closed institution, meaning that it will not succumb to any external influence.  There is virtually nothing that anyone from the outside of the system can do to change it. It relies on public funds and has no accountability to that same public. Change has to come from within or it must be dismantled and an accountable institution that actually serves the public rather than its own interests must be put into place.

Enhanced by Zemanta

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.bastique.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/8



There are reasons for what you've described. I've been one of the people who tries to get details on OPD and can make a few statements.

The Oakland Police Department, like many militarized police departments across the country, does not depend upon the city for a great deal of its funding. They get much of it from the feds--CIA, Homeland Security, etc. The department's attitude toward accountability to the community has a lot to do with that.

Also, the city council doesn't ask for or get much information about OPD business. OPD is represented to city government by one person, Deanna Santana, City Manager, and she is greatly pro-OPD decisions and requests. When the Council has a decision to make about OPD, it follows Santana's recommendations which are invariably in line with what OPD wants.

For example, $100,000 was given to the department as an "add-on" to the cost of the Frazier investigation about a month before the report was due (the consent decree allows OPD to hire when it needs personnel in order to investigate or do other work to meet deadlines, etc). It has become obvious that OPD officers were hired in temporary positions, and their duties were to find evidence of criminal acts by Occupy Oakland people. This was in addition to the part of Frazier's investigation covering the same areas.

A number of Occupiers received letters from OPD sergeants asking them to get in touch if they had seen or had any evidence of criminal behavior by other Occupiers. The people who received the letters had been arrested by OPD so it appeared that is where those particular names (and addresses, etc.) were obtained--kind of a dumb way to dig up dirt on Occupy.

We assume the department was trying to get something to put up against what was obviously going to be (and was) the final Frazier report's really damning evidence against OPD behavior with Occupy Oakland. The $100,000 was a complete waste if that was, as is very probable, its purpose. But the Council never asked why when it voted the $100,000; Santana recommended it.

The over $52 million that the Council has paid to plaintiffs on behalf of officers found liable in suits based on denial of civil rights to Oakland citizens was and is completely the decision of the City Council--there is no legal requirement for the City to pay any of these damages for the officers yet they invariably do and have for years. The amount goes far beyond what is paid by other cities such as San Jose and San Francisco, and those payments are required by their city charters.

In addition, the City is required to pay over $3 million every year for the costs of continuing the consent decree, yet I heard de la Fuente complaining about this in a Council meeting as if it had nothing to do with the fact that OPD is years past its deadline and shows no evidence of taking care of the most important issues it is required to correct, especially use of force policies and procedures. He was actually blaming this required payment for a great deal of the social service cuts made in this year's city budget--and layoffs of city employees!

This cost is very much due to OPD not reforming their "use of force" reporting and investigation--which has to be done anytime a weapon is unholstered, then up to and including the killing of an unarmed civilian. Yet OPD reporting and investigations are as we all know so shoddy as to be rejected by Oakland residents with almost any awareness of how OPD treats the community, especially communities of color.

Perhaps the strengthening of federal oversight will change this failure. Nobody and nothing in the way the Oakland city government handles--or refuses to handle--OPD will.


Your subheading--don't you mean to say " . . . musings OF an overgrown child . . ." ?

Ooops! Fixing it now.


This is really a serious issue to consider. According to the writemypapers review, most of the people occupied the area. The court will give justice to it.

ranya ditaruh di musik, sementara masih hanya bermailing 7
jual baja h beam
jual pipa boiler
jual plat abrex 400
jual plat asme516 grade70
jual plat astm a285 c
jual plat astm516 70
jual plat boiler
jual plat hardox
jual plat hb 400
jual plat high strenght
jual plat high tensile sm490 yb
Pabrik Wiremesh
Supplier Besi Unp Baja
Harga besi wf
Jual sch 40
Jual sch 40
Supplier bondek
Supplier besi hollow
undangan pernikahan ada foto
Pabrik Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 80
Agen Besi Unp Baja
Jual besi wf
Jual Jaket Parka
Jaket Parka
Jual Jaket Parka
Jaket Parka
undangan pernikahan kalender
undangan pernikahan bahasa inggris islam
undangan pernikahan islami
undangan pernikahan unik dan murah
undangan pernikahan modern
undangan pernikahan online
undangan pernikahan
undangan pernikahan amplop surat
undangan pernikahan simple
undangan pernikahan murah
undangan pernikahan unik
undangan pernikahan artis
undangan pernikahan modern
undangan pernikahan artis
undangan pernikahan arab
undangan pernikahan
undangan pernikahan
Jual besi hollow
Jual besi hollow
Toko besi siku
Toko pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80
undangan pernikahan bentuk tas
Supplier Besi H beam
Agen Wiremesh Besi baja
Jual plat kapal besi baja
Pabrik besi beton master steel ms
Supplier besi hollow
Supplier besi hollow
Toko pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80
Toko besi hollow
undangan pernikahan ada fotonya
Supplier Besi Beton
Toko Wiremesh Besi baja
Supplier plat kapal besi baja
Pabrik besi beton ksty
Toko besi hollow
Toko besi hollow
Toko Plat besi
Toko besi beton Sni Ulir Polos
undangan pernikahan aneh
Jual Wiremesh Besi baja
Toko plat kapal besi baja
Pabrik besi beton krakatau steel
Agen besi hollow
Agen besi hollow
Toko besi h beam
Toko besi wf baja
undangan pernikahan amplop
Pabrik Welded Beam T beam King Queen Cross Castellated Beam
Harga Wiremesh Besi baja
Agen plat kapal besi baja
Distributor besi siku baja
Pabrik besi beton gunung garuda
Harga pipa besi
Harga pipa besi
Toko besi unp
Toko Plat besi plat kapal
undangan pernikahan online
Pabrik Plat Bordes Kembang
Supplier Besi Siku Baja
Harga besi siku baja
Pabrik besi beton delcoprima
Jual pipa besi
Jual pipa besi
Toko besi cnp
Toko besi h beam baja
undangan pernikahan anti mainstream
Pabrik Plat Besi Hitam
Agen Besi Siku Baja
Jual besi siku baja
Pabrik besi beton cakra steel cs
Supplier pipa besi
Supplier pipa besi
Toko besi hollow
Toko besi cnp
undangan pernikahan cantik dan murah
Pabrik Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel
Toko Besi Siku Baja
Supplier besi siku baja
Pabrik besi beton bjku
Toko pipa besi
Toko pipa besi
Toko besi beton Sni Ulir Polos
undangan pernikahan unik
Pabrik Jual Besi Siku Baja

coach outlet online true religion outlet store coach factory outlet persol balenciaga shoes true religion jeans sale coach canada outlet pandora charms sale michael kors outlet online pandora charms nike air force under armour shoes stone island hoodie coach outlet store diamondbacks jerseys coach outlet online michael kors bags christian louboutin shoes persol sunglasses nike outlet store cnaada goose outlet store michael kors outlet clearance adidas outlet store cheap jordan shoes pandora sale clearance ugg outlet ralph lauren outlet moncler outlet online true religion nike outlet chrome hearts outlet store michael kors outlet online adidas yeezy boost lacoste polo shirts cheap mbt shoes nike shoes canada goose outlet store air jordan uk birkenstock shoes fitflops pandora jewelry canada ugg outlet prada outlet suicoke sandals miu miu shoes orioles jerseys nike tn nike factory outlet louboutin outlet dodgers jerseys mlb jerseys coach outlet online coach factory outlet online true religion jeans polo ralph lauren outlet online hydro flask cup raiders jerseys browns jerseys ugg boots outlet nike air max schweiz nike air force 1 canada goose outlet hermes bags yeti coach handbags nike outlet pandora outlet asics shoes ed hardy shoes coach outlet store online prada outlet jordan shoes for sale versace clothing christian louboutin outlet barcelona jersey pandora charms outlet vikings jerseys louboutin outlet coach factory outlet coach outlet sale adidas sneakers cheap soccer jerseys cheap snapbacks salomon shoes david yurman jewelry fred perry brewers jerseys oakley sunglasses outlet dolce & gabbana sunglasses manolo blahnik outlet moncler outlet online nike tn prada outlet online michael kors outlet clearance costa sunglasses sale michael kors purse kendra scott suicoke sandals ysl outlet titans jersey celine outlet coach factory outlet store gymshark clothing ralph lauren outlet moncler jacka coach outlet online puma shoes reds jerseys curry 4 shoes kate spade outlet ralph lauren outlet online coach outlet clearance true religion nike hyperdunk denver broncos jersey ed hardy ronaldo jerseys kate spade outlet david yurman pandora jewelry outlet cheap maui jim sunglasses nike blazer juicy couture coach factory outlet online jordan retro 11 the north face jackets yankees jerseys true religion outlet store nobis jackets mcm handbags canada goose nike factory store coach outlet online ed hardy minnesota vikings jersey pandora jewelry coach outlet online hydro flask lids kate spade cheap mlb jerseys kobe shoes bape hoodie true religion outlet kendra scott nike outlet christian louboutin shoes off white clothing cheap jerseys cardinals jerseys pandora jewelry outlet north face outlet store coach factory outlet coach bags ralph lauren outlet miu miu handbags nike outlet store buffalo bills jersey adidas shoes nike air max 2018 cheap jordans asics outlet off white shirt fred perry canada goose sale nike free flyknit adidas outlet store cheap air jordans ferragamo outlet pandora charms outlet nike roshe run pandora charms ugg boots sale polo ralph lauren outlet online cheap nike shoes air jordan shoes converse shoes cubs jerseys jimmy choo shoes coach factory outlet mac cosmetics louis vuitton purses true religion outlet store nfl jerseys ugg boots pittsburgh steelers jersey north face jackets pandora charms coach outlet canada cheap oakley sunglasses coach outlet online fitflops outlet coach factory outlet michael kors outlet store christian louboutin outlet kate spade outlet online coach outlet online louboutin pas cher nike air max 90 louboutin outlet toms shoes canada goose coats adidas wings shoes hermes canada goose coats kate spade handbags converse shoes parajumpers jacket maui jim sunglasses ralph lauren sale clearance uk cheap nfl jerseys air max outlet coach outlet store adidas yeezy boost 350 giuseppe zanotti shoes david yurman ugg boots true religion jeans pandora charms toms jets jersey coach outlet store coach outlet store coach outlet canada coach outlet sale coach handbags ecco outlet pandora charms outlet nfl jerseys coach outlet store air jordan retro nba jerseys oakley sunglasses outlet hydro flask sale cheap ray ban sunglasses kappa clothing white sox jerseys coach factory outlet cheap jordan shoes rockies jerseys marc jacobs handbags tods outlet online adidas uk cardinals jerseys louboutin shoes coach outlet online swarovski jewelry outlet air max pas cher fitflops coach factory outlet online moncler jacken kate spade outlet online jordan pas cher coach outlet online cheap air jordans kobe 11 coach factory outlet mbt shoes coach outlet air max ugg boots women cheap jordans rolex watches moncler jackets coach factory outlet coach outlet online pandora jewelry outlet revolution 3 cincinnati bengals jersey birkenstock outlet store pandora jewelry store coach factory outlet online coach outlet store online clearance true religion outlet store prada outlet louboutin outlet jordan shoes north face outlet off white clothing polo outlet store nobis outlet coach factorty outlet online clarks ferragamo belts durant shoes columbia outlet store yeezy shoes coach outlet store pandora jewelry outlet north face outlet store polo outlet store christian louboutin toms moncler pas cher coach outlet online kate spade outlet air max plus nike roshe ugg boots coach factorty outlet store adidas nmd r1 coach factory outlet online ralph lauren uk moncler coats mac makeup miu miu shoes true religion jeans outlet mcm outlet camisetas futbol baratas coach outlet online coach outlet online gucci outlet online cheap jordan shoes ralph lauren polo jordan 4 moncler jackets air jordans fila shoes coach factory outlet pandora charms sale michael kors outlet clearance adidas outlet converse shoes true religion jeans red sox jerseys ed hardy outlet adidas ultra boost pandora jewelry yeti cup coach outlet online coach outlet pandora charms sale clearance adidas outlet online mont blanc pen costa sunglasses sale coach factory outlet michael kors outlet christian louboutin shoes timberland boots cheap snapbacks moncler outlet online michael kors outlet online canada goose coats nike blazer adidas outlet online eagles jersey coach handbags clearance chi flat iron patriots jerseys canada goose ugg italia kate spade outlet online cheap jordans canada goose coats air jordan shoes hermes belt pandora charms sale clearance adidas wings nike outlet online fitflop sale yeezy shoes coach outlet canada city royals jerseys nike outlet online coach outlet online north face outlet fitflops oakley outlet cheap handbags falcons jerseys kate spade outlet store kate spade outlet online coach outlet online curry 5 shoes coach factory outlet online jordan 31 superdry clothing nike kd 10 moncler outlet online coach factory outlet online nike shoes mont blanc mbt shoes ralph lauren outlet canada goose outlet store christian louboutin shoes nike sneakers gucci outlet store kate spade outlet sale cheap ugg boots ralph lauren outlet uggs outlet coach outlet online prada handbags canada goose coats air max shoes adidas yeezy boost ralph lauren pas cher coach outlet online indianapolis colts jerseys y3 shoes christian louboutin outlet cheap mlb jerseys kate spade handbags uggs canada giuseppe zanotti outlet store jordan 12 true religion jeans valentino outlet moncler jackets pandora rings kate spade bags air jordan 4 cheap air max canada goose outlet store cheap jordans for sale polo ralph lauren outlet bathing ape ugg italia stone island sale red bottoms oakley outlet coach outlet online coach outlet store juicy couture kate spade outlet online polo ralph lauren outlet pandora charms sale clearance coach outlet online seattle seahawks jersey nike basketball shoes gucci outlet online uggs outlet valentino outlet coach factory outlet online ugg boots adidas neo shoes nike free run coach outlet online air max 2017 fivefingers shoes jordan 3 yeezy shoes philipp plein outlet ray ban sunglasses outlet pandora charms coach outlet clearance rolex replica watches mbt shoes kobe 12 vibram fivefingers outlet dolce & gabbana Outlet air max coach handbags salvatore ferragamo shoes ugg outlet sale coach purse jaguars jersey ralph lauren uk ralph lauren outlet online nhl jerseys air jordan shoes houston texans jerseys jordan 12 persol sunglasses sale retro 11 adidas ultra boost kate spade handbags cheap jordans free shipping gymshark sale pandora charms snapback hats marlins jerseys pandora jewelry outlet canada goose coats nike shoes michael kors bags air jordan shoes valentino michael kors handbags outlet ugg ferragamo outlet hermes outlet store fitflops sale clearance supreme clothing instyler ionic styler pandora canada ed hardy uboutin shoes adidas superstars air max nike outlet store seahawks jerseys michael kors outlet online coach factory outlet coach bags asics shoes nike sneakers yeti tumbler cowboys jerseys kevin durant shoes vans shoes coach factory outlet online uggs outlet mulberry handbags coach outlet ugg outlet clearance air max 2017 michael kors outlet online moncler ferragamo outlet store toms shoes true religion outlet saints jerseys michael kors outlet clearance coach outlet online coach factory outlet online clarks shoes christian louboutin outlet adidas store valentino shoes cheap nfl jerseys guess clothing celine outlet christian louboutin outlet adidas nmd runner chelsea jersey nike outlet store cheap jordans stone island sale asics running shoes coach outlet store online broncos jerseys coach outlet store online nike factory store coach factory outlet coach outlet online fitflops outlet gucci bags coach outlet online off-white clothing coach outlet store online ralph lauren uk polo ralph lauren outlet online pandora jewelry outlet kendra scott maui jim cazal outlet fitflops sale clearance michael kors outlet clearance nike outlet online birkenstock sandals coach outlet online kate spade outlet online ugg outlet adidas yeezy shoes nike factory store coach handbags outlet uggs outlet online gymshark sale air jordan 14 coach outlet clearance ubiq shoes fitflops sale clearance fitflops canada goose le coq sportif louboutin outlet true religion outlet christian louboutin sale adidas nmd nike outlet online nike outlet online fjallraven kanken canada goose outlet polo outlet michael kors outlet store timberland outlet oakley sunglasses wholesale hydro flask sale ralph lauren polo coach outlet rolex replica watches for sale nike outlet store adidas outlet online pandora outlet air jordan 3 moncler jackets michael kors factory outlet coach factory outlet online ed hardy nike outlet store online david yurman bracelet michael kors outlet clearance louboutin outlet christian louboutin shoes uggs outlet ugg boots clearance devil rays jerseys ravens jerseys angels jerseys soccer shoes chaussures christian louboutin lacoste outlet louis vuitton ed hardy outlet soccer jerseys pandora charms cheap jordan shoes ray ban sunglasses coach outlet online michael kors outlet online packers jersey yeezy shoes gucci outlet online mcm outlet store balenciaga triples ralph lauren polo air max 2017 jordans coach factory outlet coach outlet online air max 270 ugg outlet store nike max adidas shoes air jordan coach outlet mulberry bags sale air huarache christian louboutin sale michael kors outlet mlb jerseys coach factory outlet online prada sunglasses air jordan cheap snapbacks prada outlet malone souliers shoes jimmy choo shoes cheap jordan shoes toms outlet online coach outlet store polo ralph lauren outlet online michael kors outlet online air max 97 fitflops sale clearance polo ralph lauren outlet coach outlet online moncler outlet online kate spade outlet foamposite shoe twins jerseys givenchy handbags true religion outlet store coach outlet online nike flip-flops tigers jerseys adidas ultra boost air max 2015 fitflops sale clearance air max louis vuitton outlet online coach outlet online true religion outlet rangers jersey ed hardy outlet kobe shoes new england patriots jersey uggs outlet yeezy shoes air jordan retro pandora jewelry canada ugg pas cher hermes bags coach outlet store online coach outlet online vans sneakers true religion jeans swarovski crystal coach factory outlet online kate spade outlet online yeezy boost 350 louboutin outlet adidas nmd coach outlet online jordans coach outlet online valentino outlet store coach factorty outlet store canada goose outlet ralph lauren polo phillies jerseys david yurman giants jerseys coach factory outlet online san diego chargers jerseys reebok outlet mbt shoes adidas slides fitflops oakley sunglasses outlet mbt shoes outlet gucci outlet online coach outlet online true religion outlet discount oakley sunglasses christian louboutin outlet louboutin outlet louis vuitton outlet store ralph lauren outlet online birkenstock outlet blue jays jerseys uggs cheap jordan shoes coach outlet online christian louboutin outlet coach outlet store nike outlet store birkin handbags coach factory outlet pandora outlet valentino outlet pandora charms sale clearance coach factory outlet online pandora charms michael kors outlet clearance asics running shoes patriots jerseys louis vuitton outlet online birkenstocks supra shoes fitflops outlet coach outlet store coach outlet online kate spade outlet toms outlet store moncler sito ufficiale coach outlet clearance polo ralph lauren outlet fitflops sale clearance lebron 13 nba jerseys for sale north face outlet online michael kors outlet canada coach outlet online lions jerseys canada goose jackets coach handbags fila ugg outlet kyrie 2 birkenstock sandals uggs outlet

Leave a comment

Powered by Movable Type 5.2.13

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Cary Bass-Deschenes published on July 20, 2012 3:23 PM.

Five hundred words was the previous entry in this blog.

Summary: 21 June 2012 is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

About the Author

I *am* Cary Bass-Deschenes
Written by Cary Bass-Deschenes
Website © Cary Bass-Deschenes, 2003-2014. All of the content on this website is available under the CC-BY-SA 3.0 license unless otherwise indicated.